Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Dilemma of Probashi Bengalis

More than resident Bengalis, the probashis (those living outside Bengal) try desperately to hold on to their bangaliana. As long as that includes Bengali khana (food) and gana (music), it is palatable and savory, but when it comes to their fanatical love of Sourav Ganguly, the problem arises. And the problem arises with the children of the probashis, who cannot fathom why all their parents worship him. I can understand though, because I am his die-hard fan, but my son finds it difficult to see why I support KKR of Calcutta although I studied in Banaras, found my first footing in Delhi, and currently work in Bangalore. It is as blasphemous as my Brahmin neighbor having to argue with his son about the existence of all the Hindu gods. That little brat didn’t wear the sacred thread, frustrated my neighbor by asking him to summon god to the puja room, listens to Linkin Park, and is a fan of Wayne Rooney. On a more serious note, he doesn’t even utter the Gayatri mantra, a must for every Brahmin worth his sacred thread. As a true-blue, die-hard Bengali, I find this unacceptable. And I’m not talking about my neighbor’s problem.

“Ghorer Shotru Bibhishon?” I asked my son the other day when he kept cheering Robin Uthappa, the upstart batter of Royal Challengers Bangalore, as he battered the KKR bowling attack.


“Bibhishon, Bibhishon, don’t you know your Ramayana?

“Bibhishon was the brother of Ravana, who decamped and joined Rama as a spy. He had all the vital information about Ravana’s capital, Lanka, and helped Rama win. Such betrayers, over the years, are called Bibhishon. Ki bhishon! And you, being a son of two true-blue Calcuttans, are supporting Rahul Dravid? The very man who plotted with Chappell to remove Sourav from the captain’s post?”

“But you yourself say you aren’t a bong, don’t you?” was my son’s prompt defense.

“Na, I mean I might not be a bong, but then, when it comes to Leander Paes and Sourav Ganguly, I am very much a bong. Just like I am a bong when it comes to Satyajit Ray, Jim Morrisson, Mark Knopfler, Robindronath, Usha Uthup, Arunlal, Dilip Doshi, Nandan’da, Roman Polanski, and Subhas Chandra Bose.”

Aaron wasn’t listening. His eyes gleamed with joy as mine glistened with the sadness of twin blows: that of KKR’s loss to RCB and the bigger loss of a Bengali son to an alien city. I wished I could tell him how the rest of India has always been plotting against us Bengalis. From Nehru and Gandhi plotting against Subhash Bose, Raj Singh Dungarpur plotting against Pankaj Roy, CV Raman plotting against Meghnad Saha, Sunil Gavaskar plotting against Dilip Doshi, Rahul Dravid plotting against Sourav, and Mahesh Bhupati plotting against Leander Paes, it has been a long history of subterfuge by lesser races against the Bengalis. But there are sad moments in Bengali history where one Bengali has plotted against another and ousted him, like Mir Zafar against Siraj’u’daullah, or David Gilmour against Roger Waters. Sometimes we hear rumors of Chet Atkins actually squeezing Mark Knopfler’s balls before quitting Dire Straits, but we don’t want to hear such trash about Bengalis. All this bad publicity is a ploy of the lesser races of the world to malign the only non-white humans of this world, the Bengalis.

But emotions apart, Sourav is losing his plot. His team is heavy on foreign names, who aren’t delivering except Angelo Mathews, and the local boys either don’t know cricket or lack the temperament to win a match for their team. Wriddhiman Saha never looked inspired in his entire career save behind the stumps, but he is called a batter. Manoj Tiwary and Laxmi Ratan Shukla are mediocre from all angles. There’s no Ashwin, no Vinay Kumar, or Ambati Rayadu who can turn around a match for the KKR. They are good in flashes, when Sourav or Chris Gayle shine. And when they don’t we hear Sourav losing his cool about how poorly his kids performed on the field.

Has the time come to turn our coats? Maybe support Punjab? Or Delhi? My mind is uncertain about all that save one thing: KKR will definitely lose their remaining matches, one thing I’m certain about. Would I want them to win? YES. Resounding yes. But do I trust them to win? Do I have faith in them? NO.


“Arijit, you there?”

“Yeah, tell me Atanu.”

“Thought I would share something really unfortunate with you.”

“What is it?” I was alarmed.

“My younger son has turned into a fan of MS Dhoni, of Chennai Super Kings. Am wondering how to bring him back to faith. Ki hobe bolo toe?”


Aritra De said...

Ki hobe amader next generation probashi Bangalider ...... MohunBagan-EastBengal chere shudu EPL......

Is that the price we pay for being "probashi"? Well well .......

Aritra De

sanchali said...

ii totally agree with you. I don't care where I live I will be supporting bengaland bangalis all through
Politics have killed us bengalis

Amitabh said...

I love Bengalis specially the fairer and the beautiful ones except my friend called Arijit Ghosh ..but truly KKR sucks big time ..I'd probably support KKR if MS Dhoni was captain of KKR ..which should look like an East India team rather than a projected Bengali team.
luv, James

ATANU said...

Long time back, there was a saying, which most Bongs would love to reiterate "What bengal thinks today india thinks tommorow". Some how these days I get a feeling what bengal thinks today nobody even cares to think about it tommorow. My feeling is, in today's world appreciation should be based on merit and not driven by bias stateism. Thats my take though ...

Lazyani said...

Now , now Shuvo. Don't get excited about a tournament run by a crook. Why don't you take a look at people called Pranobbabu, Shan, Shantanu, Shreya...............

And if you condescend to look into I league football, all good teams have a goalkeeper from Bengal.

There , have I given you a food for thought or a point to be ridiculed???

As for the next gen, don't you worry.Send them to USA or Europe and wait for them to return as a greater Bengali, albeit of the probashi kind.

Mampi said...

IPL is now in hot soup anyway.
And taking inspiration from this post, I guess I should do a post on how the world conspired against Punjabi's.
See what happened to hockey once the Punjabis were ignored ??

Anonymous said...

U had commented abot Ashwin not in KKR, well Ashwin is busy playing tennis at SRS..... :)